Like a Fiery Meteor: The Life of Joseph F. Smith: A Review

Joseph F. Smith (1838–1917) is a towering figure in Latter-day Saint history, so I have waited and hoped for an academically rigorous biography about him for years. Stephen C Taysom delivered on that hope this year in Like a Fiery Meteor: The Life of Joseph F. Smith

The flavor of Taysom’s work reminded me of John G. Turner’s Brigham Young: Pioneer Prophet—a thoroughly researched biographical work that places a prophet-president in his context. Like Turner, Taysom’s work reveals the complexities of Joseph F. Smith as a person, allowing readers to get to know Joseph F. Smith more intimately. At times, the story takes a shocking turn, such as discussion of Joseph F. Smith’s violent tendencies or his lying about the performances of post-manifesto plural marriages. Even while showing Joseph F. at his worst, however, Taysom does contextualize Smith’s actions in a way that makes sense of them.

Taysom’s biography of Joseph F. Smith is very different from previous biographies about Smith. Francis M. Gibbons’ Joseph F. Smith: Patriarch and Preacher, Prophet of God is hagiographic to the point that a bullet list of life events and accomplishments would be about as useful for getting to know Joseph F. Smith. (To be honest, I struggled to get through Gibbons’ work because of how overly hagiographic it was, even though it’s relatively short.) The Life of Joseph F. Smith by Joseph Fielding Smith is valuable for the access it had to both primary sources and memories of the subject, but it is also the effort of a son and church leader to put his father and ecclesiastical predecessor in the best light possible. Teachings of the Presidents of the Church: Joseph F. Smith—the official church manual from around 2000—is a great collection of his teachings, but the history sections provide an inaccurate view of Joseph F. Smith, especially when it comes to his temper. Like a Fiery Meteor is of a different mold altogether and shows a different person because of its relatively objective approach.

Something that could have strengthened Like a Fiery Meteor was to not overstate the importance of Joseph F. Smith. President Smith is extremely important, but occasionally statements were made that shortsold the contributions of other, earlier Church leaders in an effort to hype up Joseph F. Smith. For example, Taysom states that: “Since Joseph Smith had introduced the concept [of proxy temple work] in the 1840s, it had struggled to find a champion, someone who possessed a passion for the work of the temple as well as a capacity for doctrinal thinking that could place proxy temple work within the larger whole of Mormon belief and practice” (357). This completely overlooks the role of Orson Pratt and Wilford Woodruff doing those exact things. Orson Pratt was one of the earliest individuals in the Church to systematically trace out his ancestors and to make sure that proxy baptisms were performed for them. He also oversaw the addition of many of the most important temple-related texts from Joseph Smith to the Doctrine and Covenants. Wilford Woodruff played a huge role in codifying temple rites and administration and for shifting the Latter-day Saint views towards performing proxy work to create a family-centric (rather than Church-centric) afterlife with his 1894 revelation. Many of the ideas that Joseph F. Smith articulated in his vision that is now D&C 138 had previously been expressed by Wilford Woodruff. Thus, on a couple of occasions Taysom was prone to overstate the contributions of Joseph F. Smith.

That concern aside, the book offers a lot of interesting and insightful discussion about Joseph F. Smith’s life and contributions to the faith. One area of discussion that I found particularly interesting was Joseph F. Smith’s role in establishing doctrine and interpretation of scriptures in the Church. In a lot of discussions outside of Taysom’s work, Joseph F. has tended to be overshadowed by James E. Talmage and B. H. Roberts as a notable Latter-day Saint theologian during his time and by his son, Joseph Fielding Smith, after his time. What Tayson points out is that Joseph Fielding Smith was largely trained by his father in how he interpreted scripture and doctrine. Before either Talmage or Roberts published notable works, Joseph F. was to go-to church leader to settle doctrinal debates, and his time as president of the Church allowed him to normalize his views and approaches. Joseph Fielding Smith’s efforts to answer letters in print seems to have been modeled on his father’s work. Taysom does a great job of highlighting how deeply our belief system was impacted by Joseph F. Smith.

As the first academic biography of Joseph F. Smith, Stephen C Taysom’s Like a Fiery Meteor: The Life of Joseph F. Smith is an important and long-overdue contribution to Latter-day Saint history.

11 comments for “Like a Fiery Meteor: The Life of Joseph F. Smith: A Review

  1. In all seriousness though, one thing I discovered writing a biography is that it is difficult to overstate some contributions because you are not looking for who ELSE is working on x, y, or z. In a book this long and involved, an author could never finish if they checked every possible other person working on something, unless they published widely on it. The great thing is that reviews like this bring those hidden things out. You had knowledge I couldn’t or didn’t find, and my relative ignorance brought your knowledge to the fore, It is very useful and it brings up a lot of other questions, not the leas of which is why so many men were working on the same problem (and why JFS didn’t mentions it? Might have helped!!)

  2. One’s search for prior literature is never as fruitful as just after the corrected page proofs have gone to press. Thanks for the review, Chad, and congratulations on the book, S. Taysom.

  3. That makes sense, Taysom. I suppose that some of my own research and interests just happen to be in the particular area that made it so I’ve been aware of those contributions from other people.
    I hope that it still comes through that I thought you did a great job and that I enjoyed the journey of reading Like a Fiery Meteor. I love Mormonism at the turn of the twentieth century and am grateful that you went through the years of work and effort to make this biography a reality!

  4. I think it’s well-done review. After 25 years of research, 10 of those on this book, it comes as no surprise to me that there are scholars who know far more about pieces of his life than I do. That was one of the major challenges that kept me up at night. “What don’t I know that I don’t know that someone else knows.” My first book was heavily theoretical and very narrowly focused. That’s the kind of writing I learned to do in graduate school. I call it “small writing” when I teach my students how to research and write. “Writing big” has its virtues but I’m not tempted to do it again.

  5. Oh and the other nasty thing about a book project this huge is that by the time I was done researching and writing a section, the prior historiography had changed. No matter what logical positivists think, history is dynamic.

  6. I had the chance to interview Steve a couple of times about his book. A particular example of the historiography changing was the Mountain Meadows Massacre. I thoroughly enjoyed this biography and have recommended it to family members. The strongest part of the book was Steve’s ability to put JFS’s actions in context. When you see the life he grew up with, a lot is explained. In fact, I will be rating this higher on my radio program than even Vengeance is Mine (which got three interviews from me). It was close, but this one is better on my book of the year list.

  7. PS: While Steve is swearing (literally) to never to another book like this again, I’d love to see him do Heber J. Grant. Anyone else on board? We could start a petition. ;)

  8. Heber J. Grant is the next church president I’m hoping for a big biography on. I wouldn’t mind if it was Taysom who wrote it.

  9. Whoever takes on Heber can hopefully pick up where Ronald Walker left off. He was working on one and then stopped for some reason.

Comments are closed.